It was like a basketball team being down by 20 points with 30 seconds left, the fake electors were just a way to keep fouling until something worked or the clock ran out.
Scenario 1, Pence says 'Ah, here are the REAL votes from Arizona, I can just round file the ones the Archivist sent over"
Trump wins because he gets all the votes that count
Scenario 2, Pence says "I iz confuzzled, I have two sets of votes from Arizona, so I'mma just set them aside, they cancel each other out and none of them count"
Trump wins because once six states no longer count, Trump has a Majority of the 44 that do.
Scenario 3, Pence says "I can't do this shit on a Tuesday, send all these things back and ask the state legislatures if they want to try again"
Trump wins maybe because if they had gotten this far how many states would have played along?
Scenario 4, Pence says "This is as twisted up as a spaghetti orgy, let's just have the House of Representatives vote on it"
Trump wins because when the house votes, each state delegation gets one vote and more Republican delegations (another one of the many times that 400 square miles of sheep get as much power as the entirety of Brooklyn because when the made the Constitution, mistakes were made)
Scenario 5, The Proud boys take the chamber, hang Mike Pence, install President Camacho as Maximum Leader for Life.
Note that in only one scenario and that the least likely does Pence count the fake electors votes. They were just a thing to point at to confuse the issue and foul the guy again to see if he misses both free throws and we get the rebound and score...